If you’re someone who loves role-playing games, immersive storytelling, and behind-the-scenes insights, the Out of Character podcast might already be on your radar. But with more than a hundred episodes under its belt, how do you know where to start? That’s where Reddit comes in. The podcast’s community on Reddit is a goldmine for fan favorites and hidden gems — episodes that really resonated, sparked discussion, or had moments that just stuck with people.
In this blog post, we’re diving deep into the top Reddit-recommended Out of Character episodes. We’ve sifted through subreddit threads, listener reviews, and community upvotes to bring together a curated list that highlights not just popularity, but emotional impact, storytelling brilliance, and moments that truly define the podcast’s magic.
Whether you’re a brand-new listener trying to find your entry point, or a longtime fan looking for that one episode everyone talks about, I promise this list will guide you. And more than just a list — you’ll get reasons why each episode stands out, what Redditors loved about them, and where to listen.
What Is the ‘Out of Character’ Podcast?
The Out of Character podcast is a unique blend of role-playing talk, game commentary, interviews, and community-focused discussions. While many podcasts stick strictly to game mechanics or play sessions, Out of Character sits somewhere in between: it’s not entirely “actual play,” but it’s also very much about role-play culture. The hosts explore both digital and tabletop roleplaying environments, sharing their experiences, tips, and sometimes the drama that comes with being deeply invested in roleplay communities.
The show is hosted by M9 and Nixie, two passionate role-players who bring a warm and conversational energy to the mic. Their chemistry makes for episodes that feel like catching up with friends — except those friends happen to run RP servers, design gaming mods, or organize live tabletop sessions.
Listeners who gravitate toward Out of Character often fall into a few camps:
- Story lovers, who enjoy deep dives into character creation, lore, and world-building.
- RPG players, both beginners and veterans, who want practical advice, etiquette, and insights about roleplay.
- Community-focused audience, who love hearing about server drama, modding communities, and the social side of role-playing.
You can catch the podcast on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and other major platforms. The show also often features community guests — modders, server owners, and influential roleplayers — which gives it an inclusive, grassroots feel.
One of Out of Character’s greatest strengths is its connection with its fan base. On Reddit, especially in subreddits like r/OutOfCharacterPod, listeners discuss favorite episodes, ask for recommendations, recall emotional moments, and even dig into why certain episodes changed their perspective. This sense of community makes it easier for new listeners to find episodes that resonate deeply rather than randomly browsing.
Also Read: Ted Danson Podcast: Reddit, Spotify, Apple & YouTube Podcast
Why Reddit Loves the ‘Out of Character’ Podcast
Reddit has become a powerful tool for discovery — especially when it comes to niche or passion-driven podcasts like Out of Character. Here are a few reasons why this community plays such an important role:
Authentic Listener Feedback
Unlike algorithm-driven charts or “top podcasts” lists, Reddit gives you real, unfiltered opinions from actual listeners. People don’t just vote; they post full reflections about how an episode made them feel, what surprised them, or what they want more of. This depth of feedback is something that podcast apps rarely provide.
Episode Recommendations That Matter
On subreddits like r/OutOfCharacterPod, you’ll find threads such as “Which episodes should I start with?” or “Hidden favorite episodes no one else talks about.” These threads help both new and seasoned listeners navigate the podcast’s long catalog and discover episodes that really matter to the community.
Emotional Moments & Memes
Reddit isn’t just about serious discussion — it’s also where memes, jokes, and emotional reactions thrive. Fans highlight moments that made them laugh, reflect on character relationships, or even get teary-eyed over heartfelt stories. For instance, one thread about Episode 43 noted how deeply some listeners connected with the hosts’ friendship:
“This episode literally changed the way I view Hamzah and Martin’s friendship … made me tear up.”
That kind of genuine reaction is gold for someone deciding whether to listen.
Long-Term Engagement & History
Reddit helps document the podcast’s journey. Sometimes listeners ask: “Why were old episodes archived?” or “What happened to lost episodes?” These threads preserve context and lore, making the listening experience richer.
All of this makes Reddit not just a supplement to Out of Character, but a vital partner in shaping how fans experience and appreciate the podcast.
Top Reddit-Recommended ‘Out of Character’ Podcast Episodes
Below are some of the top episodes of Out of Character, based on Reddit chatter, community votes, and recurring recommendations. Note: because the subreddit doesn’t always rank things with neat leaderboards, some episodes here are chosen for emotional impact, fan lore importance, or memorable dialogue.
Episode #1: OOC Episode 43
- Summary: In this deeply emotional episode, the hosts — particularly Hamzah — open up about their friendship with Martin. They reflect on past experiences, personal vulnerabilities, and how their relationship has grown over time.
- Reddit Fan Highlights: According to Redditors, this is one of the most “human” episodes. Many commented that the way Hamzah spoke about Martin’s influence on his life brought them close to tears.
- Why It Stands Out: It breaks away from typical gaming or RP talk and goes into real-life feelings, trust, and friendship. For listeners who appreciate the people behind the podcast — not just the role-playing — this episode is a powerful listen.
Episode #2: Deleted Solo YouTube Episode (Hamzah)
- Summary: This solo episode features Hamzah alone, sharing personal stories, reflections on life, and candid thoughts about his journey. It was once available on YouTube but was deleted/privated, making it something of a rare gem.
- Reddit Fan Highlights: Several Reddit users expressed a longing to find this version, praising his vulnerability, humor, and the straightforward way he talks about relationships and mental health.
- Why It Stands Out: The solo format gives Hamzah space to be raw and unfiltered. Fans say it feels like sitting down and having a long, honest conversation with a friend — something you don’t always get in a group-based podcast setup.
Episode #3: Tarayummy University & Theatre Bug (Old Favorite)
- Summary: While not a single episode, these two recurring topics come up on Reddit in episode recommendation threads: “Tarayummy University” and “Theatre Bug” are frequently mentioned as standout story arcs or themes.
- Reddit Fan Highlights: In a thread on r/SlushyNoobz, one user wrote:
“Good earlier one I like is Tarayummy University or Theatre Bug!! … more recently Happy Canada Day and life is a box of chocolates.”
- Why It Stands Out: These arcs are valued for their creativity, role-play depth, and charm. They showcase the podcast’s ability to weave whimsical storytelling with deeper character moments.
Episode #4: Any Solo Reflection Episodes
- Summary: Beyond just one solo episode, Redditors often refer to “solo pods” where either host reflects on roleplaying, identity, or community. These may not always be listed clearly in episode guides but come up in older discussion threads.
- Reddit Fan Highlights: Fans repeatedly ask for links to solo-reflection episodes, indicating their importance in understanding the hosts’ personal evolution.
- Why It Stands Out: These episodes offer introspection, giving long-term listeners context, emotional breadth, and a deeper connection to the hosts’ journeys.
Episode #5: Reboot / Rebrand Discussion
- Summary: On Reddit, some users discuss a phase where old episodes were archived during a “rebrand.” This was not just a technical or administrative change — it meant some content became less accessible, and fans debated which episodes should have stayed live.
- Reddit Fan Highlights: The thread titled “What happened to the rest of the podcast eps?” shows how invested the community is in preserving older episodes.
- Why It Stands Out: It’s a meta-episode of sorts: the conversation itself is a part of the show’s history. For anyone interested in the legacy of Out of Character, this is a must-follow thread, because it reveals how the community and the creators interact over time.
How to Find More Hidden-Gem Episodes on Reddit
If you want to dig even deeper into the Out of Character universe, Reddit is your best friend. Here are some tips:
- Use Subreddit Search Smartly
- Head to r/OutOfCharacterPod and use keywords like “favorite episode,” “hidden gem,” or specific episode numbers.
- Sort by “Top” → “All Time” to find threads that have been highly upvoted and discussed.
- Follow Recommendation Threads
- Some users periodically ask for suggestions: “What episode changed you?” or “Where should a new listener start?” These threads are gold for curated picks.
- Save or bookmark recommendation threads so you can refer back later.
- Explore Solo / Reflection Episodes
- Look for posts that mention “solo ep,” “Hamzah alone,” or “Nixie reflections.” These often highlight episodes that aren’t necessarily part of the main arc but are deeply personal.
- Be Mindful of Spoilers
- If you haven’t listened to a lot yet, use Reddit’s spoiler tags or avoid “episode recap” threads until after you’ve tuned in.
- Alternatively, read only the first few comments — often, the top comment will have a spoiler-free summary.
- Join the Conversation
- Ask your own questions: “Which episodes made you cry?” or “Any episodes where they really talk about real life?”
- Contribute to threads: once you’ve listened to some, you can give back by sharing your thoughts. Not only does this help you connect with the community, but it also helps others.
Who Should Listen to ‘Out of Character’?
New Listeners:
If you’re just discovering Out of Character, start with the Reddit-recommended episodes mentioned above. They give you a mix of emotional depth, roleplay culture, and personality — everything that makes the podcast special. These episodes help you understand who the hosts are, how they think, and why their community matters.
Long-Term Fans:
Even if you’re already a regular listener, Reddit can help you rediscover episodes you may have missed or forgotten. Reflection episodes and solo talks are frequently underrated, but they often carry the most emotional weight.
RPG / Roleplay Enthusiasts:
If you play tabletop RPGs or are involved in roleplay communities (online or offline), you’ll appreciate the discussions around etiquette, server drama, and character creation. The podcast doesn’t just entertain — it educates and reflects.
Story Lovers & Podcast Connoisseurs:
For those who love character arcs, real talk, and narrative depth, Out of Character offers a unique blend. The episodes recommended by Reddit are particularly strong in these areas, making them a great jumping-off point.
Also Read: Whatever Podcast Girl List – Names, Guests, and Social Media Highlights
Reddit has proven itself to be more than just a feedback loop for Out of Character — it’s a living, breathing part of the podcast ecosystem. The episodes that keep surfacing on the subreddit are not just “popular”; they’re deeply meaningful, emotionally resonant, and often transformative for listeners.
By following Reddit’s guidance, you get more than just a list of pretty good episodes — you access a community’s shared heart. Whether you’re tuning in for the first time or seeking to relive your favorite moments, the selections above are a powerful way to connect with what makes Out of Character truly special.
If you enjoyed this list and want more curated podcast content, make sure to subscribe to Podcastlite.com!
We bring you handpicked episode guides, Reddit-curated recommendations, exclusive updates, and deep dives into your favorite shows. Don’t miss out — join our community and discover your next podcast obsession.
